Business hospitality: does a client's courtesy demonstrate interest?

In high-value selling, an invitation or a thoughtful gesture can facilitate contact without clarifying the client's needs. The managerial question is specific: what evidence should a team require before qualifying an opportunity following business hospitality?

What the literature establishes

Dennis T. Regan (1971, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology) experimentally examined how receiving a favour affected compliance with a subsequent request to buy raffle tickets. Receiving a favour increased purchases, and liking for the requester was not sufficient to explain the effect. A favourable response may therefore reflect the interpersonal situation, rather than simply the appeal of what is offered.

Reciprocity extends beyond gifts

Robert B. Cialdini, Joyce E. Vincent, Stephen K. Lewis, José Catalan, Diane Wheeler and Betty Lee Darby (1975, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology) studied a sequence in which a large, rejected request preceded a smaller one. Their experiments support a reciprocal-concessions mechanism: the requester's apparent retreat can encourage compliance. This finding does not concern business hospitality, but it illustrates why accepting a request is not a pure measure of interest in its substance.

The premature conclusion

One might conclude that sales teams should offer more favours or engineer concessions to secure more agreements. Yet these studies establish neither a better fit between offer and need, nor a lasting relationship, nor a profitable sale. Their managerial relevance lies instead in reminding us that compliance can have several causes. (our executive and employee training programmes)

What these findings cannot determine

These experiments concern narrowly defined requests, far removed from a private banking mandate, an institutional purchase, a watch acquisition or a commodity trading contract. They cannot quantify the effect of an invitation in these Geneva sectors, where applicable rules on gifts, conflicts of interest and procurement must be checked. A pleasant meeting is therefore neither proof of value nor evidence of undue influence.

A practical check in Genève

Within SHR's « Vente à forte valeur ajoutée » programme, one possible exercise is to review, over one month, opportunities reclassified as active after an invitation permitted by the applicable rules. In private banking, international organisations, luxury watchmaking and commodity trading, require evidence in each file that goes beyond expressions of thanks: a client-stated need and an explicit criterion for evaluating the offer. Then calculate the proportion of these files containing both elements, excluding mere acceptances of invitations. This rate checks the soundness of opportunity qualification without claiming to measure hospitality's causal effect on sales. To go further: explore the High-Value Selling training in Geneva in the canton of Geneva, or browse our executive and employee training programmes in Switzerland.

In pictures: High-Value Selling in Geneva

• high-value selling
• Geneva
• research
• training geneva